Girls and Young Women as Role Models
I can’t get an image out of my mind of a young woman, a teenager, who was on the morning news recently.
She, along with three young men, also teenagers, were being interviewed because they did something heroic on their way home from their Junior Prom. (I’m purposefully being vague because I don’t want to call out this young woman too vigorously.)
The kids were being hailed as heroes.
Indeed, their actions that night were selfless and mindful and heroic.
In the interview, the young woman never smiled.
She didn’t say anything.
What I can’t get out of my head is the way she stood next to one of the boys—the one doing most of the talking—and straightened her already straight blonde hair with her hand during the interview.
I want to give her the benefit of the doubt: maybe she was nervous, camera-shy, uncomfortable, embarrassed, bored.
She did seem bored.
She also seemed like arm candy.
I’m not sure what the point was of having her in the interview in the first place.
I assume she took a bigger role the night of the emergency.
To be fair to her, there was a boy in the line-up of interviewees who didn’t contribute to the conversation either.
But he at least seemed interested.
The young woman just seemed apathetic.
She seemed checked out, like she would much rather have been sitting with her friends talking about fashion and the dance.
And, maybe everyone—except for the leader of the group—would have been happier doing that, too.
There’s nothing wrong with that.
My problem is that in a televised interview, she portrayed herself like every cliché of a modern white teenage girl who only cares about how she looks.
And it made me angry.
I thought young women had moved the needle on that characterization.
It’s not just about how you look!
It’s about your contribution to the conversation, the scene, your community, the world.
I realize she is one young woman caught in one moment and quite possibly she contributes a lot to many other things in her life.
But women don’t need more PR, showing women being vacuous, airy, arm candy.
I don’t want young women to think they’re only along for the ride.
I want young women to put themselves behind the wheel.

Say something.
Give us your point of view.
The teenager in this interview had no purpose.
And that made me sad, too.
To be honest, had that been me in the interview at that age, I wouldn’t have said anything either.
But I wouldn’t have agreed to be on TV in the first place.
This young woman did herself and girls and women the country over a disservice.
I would love to hear her tell me what her role was the night of the emergency.
How did she feel being able to help a family?
I want a role model not a cliché.
I want someone with agency.
My husband tells me I’m being too judgmental. (You might agree.)
In an effort to clear my head, I’m going to give that young woman a purpose: She made me understand that we have an obligation to keep writing characters that kids can root for or relate to or emulate or strive to become.

Male or female, they need a purpose beyond being a place holder, making sure their hair looks good.
We want Elle Woods, Katniss, Hermione Granger, Merci Suarez, Mia Tang, India Opal….
Thanks for letting me get that off my mind.
Have a great week,
~ Gail
(Tick tock)
Before you go, don’t forget to sign up for my mailing list, below:


Hi Gail!
I would tend to agree with you – Hey girl, do something, don’t just stand there! I’m always frustrated when there’s a group of participants but only one person speaks. I want to understand everyone’s perspectives.
But your article got me thinking – what if holding space WAS her role? What if she is the strong, silent type? We usually associate that stereotype with men, but that doesn’t necessarily exclude her. She could be the power behind the throne (geez, Kel, how many cliches can you throw into one paragraph?) Perhaps it was her quiet, steadfast belief that gave the others permission and/or power to perform when they were most needed.
I know, that doesn’t sit right with me, either. I want to see Miss Flat-iron Lipgloss leading the charge, doing the heroic thing. But truthfully, I’d probably still criticize her for looking too good while doing the thing, you know? I want to see the flawed hero in action, and it’s difficult to empathize with someone whose greatest crisis is split ends.
I’d say that you have a beautiful challenge right in front of you. Tell the backstory of that girl. Show us what she’s been through to become the reflection of perfection. (ooo, that’s a good title!) Has she dealt with braces, freckles, one leg shorter than the other? Apathetic parents, a broken home? Seeking guidance from fashion magazines, a crisis of self? There’s so much rich, juicy material there!
She impressed you for a reason. She’s begging you to give her life.
Hi Kelly! Thoughtful comment! Thank you. I guess being a bookmark or a bookend is important. She COULD have been there for support. I suppose if I squint really hard, I could see that. Maybe the talker would have fainted if she wasn’t propping him up. And there she is being all hero-y again. But, oh my goodness, it was like I was watching a horror movie and screaming at the actress “Do something! Move!” But, alas, her only visible (I’ll give you that) contribution was a brush of her blond hair. Maybe…she had a whole bunch of things prepared to say, but when she saw the camera light blinking, she went blank. That’s another possibility. In which case, bless her heart, and what a poop I am for calling her out! She’s a reluctant shero, who is kicking herself right now for the terrible interview and missing her chance to shine. She needs another chance. You’re right, I should wrap a story around her and give her a better ending. It’s good to hear from you!